On July 19, 1723, officials in Newport, R.I., hanged 26 sailors for piracy before a jubilant crowd.
Puritan minister Cotton Mather was pleased to get the news in Boston, 70 miles to the north. “It was the hand of the Glorious God which brought these criminals to die," he thundered from his pulpit. “Take a due notice of what you have seen in the way which these wicked men have trodden, and in the fearful end in which their way has brought them to."
English pirate Edward Low and his sidekick Charles Harris were raiding ships along trade routes from the Caribbean to New England in the spring of 1723. They left a bloody wake, having massacred an entire crew, sunk ships, cut off prisoners’ ears and burned their flesh to the bone so they would reveal where the gold and silver were hidden.
Low was one of the most infamous pirates of the Caribbean, notorious for his cruelty to prisoners. He once cut off a ship captain’s lips and roasted them before murdering his victim.
That spring Low and Harris in two vessels sailed north from the Caribbean. On June 10, 1723, they spotted a ship sailing to leeward off Long Island. They gave chase, only to find the vessel was a 20-gun warship HMS Greyhound.
Low’s ship had about 70 men and 10 cannon, while Harris had about 50 men and eight big guns. The pirates chased the Greyhound and ordered her to surrender. The captain of the British warship refused and the battle was underway. After a day of fighting, the Greyhound captured Harris’ ship, while Low managed to escape.
Most of the 35 pirates who survived the battle were taken to Newport, where they were tried, convicted and sentenced to death. Two were reprieved because they had been forced into piracy. But another sailor who joined Low under threat of torture was hanged along with the rest.
They were hanged on Gravelly Point with their captured pirate flag attached to the gallows.
"Never was there a more doleful sight in all this land than while they were standing on the stage, waiting for the stopping of their breath and the flying of their souls into the eternal world," wrote one witness. "And oh! How awful the noise of their dying moans!”
Their deaths were celebrated from New York to Boston.
“If you will not hear the warnings of your faithful pastors,” preached Mather, “hear the roarings of twenty-six terrible preachers that, in a ghastly apparition are now from the dead, calling you to turn and live unto God.”
With thanks to At the Point of a Cutlass by Greg Flemming. This story was updated in 2017.