Macy was a founder of the town of Amesbury and its first town clerk, having moved from Salisbury. His position, however, did not place him above the law, and Macy was very much breaking the law by opening his home to the visitors.
Macy was a Baptist, which already placed him in a difficult position with the Puritan leaders of Massachusetts who banned Baptists from preaching. But to make matters worse, the men now seeking shelter in his home were Quakers. One was Edward Wharton; some sources say the others included William Robinson and Marmaduke Stephenson.
Stephenson and Robinson were Quakers who had been banished from Massachusetts, but they chose to return to protest a recent law that ordered that Quakers without property who had been banished and returned to Massachusetts would be put to death. In October of that year, that's exactly what happened to Robinson and Stephenson.
For Macy, the consequences of his actions were less severe. A 1657 law made it a crime to entertain Quakers. Macy's neighbors notified the Rev. Worcester of the infraction, and he placed the matter before the General Court.
Macy pleaded innocent of holding Quaker leanings. "On a rainy morning there came to my house Edward Wharton and three men more; the said Wharton spoke to me, saying they were travelling eastward, and desired me to direct them in the way to Hampton, and asked me how far it was to Casco Bay.
"I never saw any of the men before except Wharton, neither did I inquire their names or what they were; but by their carriage I thought they might be Quakers and told them so, and desired them to pass on their way, saying to them I might possibly give offence in entertaining them; and as soon as the rain ceased (for it rained very hard) they went away, and I never saw them since.
"The time they stayed in the house was about three quarters of an hour, but I can safely affirm it was not an hour. They spoke not many words in the time neither was I at leisure to talk with them, for I came home wet to the skin immediately before they came to the house, and I found my wife sick in bed. If this does not satisfy the Honored Court I am subject to their sentence."
The explanation did not satisfy the honored court, which fined Macy 30 shillings and admonished him. The episode inspired John Greenleaf Whittier's poem, the Exiles.
With the increasing intolerance of the Puritans, the finding could not have surprised Macy. He had apparently already been planning an escape.
He had joined with Tristram Coffin in planning a new settlement -- out of the reach of the Puritan extremists. Coffin, also a Baptist, had left England at the start of the English Civil War in 1642. He had gathered a group of like-minded investors and had arranged to purchase the island of Nantucket from Macy's cousin, Thomas Mayhew.
Mayhew had settled on Martha's Vineyard where he was governor. He acquired Nantucket via a grant and purchase from the American Indians, and he was ready to sell the whole of Nantucket less a portion he retained for himself.
With Nantucket falling under the jurisdiction of New York, the new residents hoped to make it a more tolerable place. For the sum of 30 pounds and two beaver hats, the investors bought Nantucket in July of 1659 and made it their new home. The island did become the tolerant locale that the founders envisioned, with Quakers making up a large portion of the population.
Macy remained a lifelong Baptist. The Macy’s established a family there, and he died at 74 in 1682 after a successful career on Nantucket. His wife Sarah lived on another 24 years, and she did in fact become a Quaker late in life.