On March 29, 1676, old Roger Williams was one of 30 men who remained in the town of Providence. Most of the population had taken refuge on Aquidneck Island, rightly fearing an Indian attack. It was the midst of King Philip’s War, and Roger Williams tried to stop the bloodshed. He was 77 years old.
That day the Indians roamed Providence unmolested as they set fire to houses, barns, sheds and churches. They burned Roger Williams’ home, though he had long been their friend.
Williams sent an ominous letter to his brother, then staying on Aquidneck Island.
[P]repare forts for women and children at Newport and on the island or it will be shortly worse with you than us.
King Philip’s War
No U.S. war was as catastrophic as King Philip’s War. For 55 years, New England colonists had lived in peace with the Native Americans. But then Plymouth Colony grabbed too much Indian land, subjected them to a humiliating peace treaty and hanged three Wampanoags.
War broke out.
Indians attacked nearly half the towns in New England, but it was all over after 14 months of fighting. Philip was dead, his head displayed in Plymouth Colony for 20 years. As many as a thousand Indians were sold into slavery, and 5,000 were killed in battle, of sickness or starvation. Another 2,000 fled west or north. At the outset of the war, Indians comprised 30 percent of New England’s population; by the end, they were down to 15 percent.
King Philip’s War devastated New England. Plymouth Colony lost 8 percent of its adult male population. Compare that to the Civil War, in which less than 5 percent of the country’s men died.
The New England economy suffered, and it would take a century before per capita income rose to its level before the war.
Before the bloodshed, there had been about 100 towns in New England; afterward, only about 65, the rest having been burned or abandoned.
Great Swamp Massacre
Old Roger Williams did his best to stanch the bloodshed. As the colony’s leader, he and Rhode Island’s largest tribe, the Narragansetts, tried to stay out of the escalating violence.
Williams had consistently upheld the Indians’ rights. He bought the Indians’ land from them, instead of appropriating it, and he learned their language, publishing a guide to it in 1643, A Key Into the Language of America.
At the outset of King Philip’s War, the Narragansetts had signed a treaty of neutrality with Massachusetts Bay Colony.
Knowing this, King Philip sent the women, children and infirm from warring tribes to safety with the Narragansetts. But a 1,000-man militia from three colonies – Plymouth, Massachusetts and Connecticut – invaded Rhode Island and massacred the Narragansett winter settlement in the Great Swamp, now South Kingstown. Seven hundred Indian men, women and children died in agony.
The Narragansetts had no choice but to go to war. The Narragansett sachem Canonchet assembled an army that attacked towns in Central Massachusetts, Rhode Island and, finally, Providence.
Old Roger Williams
As Providence burned, a group of Indians from several tribes assembled on the banks of a salt cove across from the town. Williams walked out to talk with them across the water, his back to the burning town.
The conversation between the Indian warriors and the old minister lasted an hour.
Roger Williams asked them why they burned and killed their kind neighbors. He told them,
This house of mine now burning before mine eyes hath lodged kindly some thousands of you these ten years.
They said Rhode Island had joined the other colonies in the Great Swamp massacre.
In a letter to his brother, Williams recounted his reply:
I told them they … had forgot they were mankind and ran around the country like wolves tearing the innocent and peacable….They confessed they were in a strange way.
Roger Williams then warned them that it was almost time to plant. The Indians said they didn’t care about planting; they would take food from the English. They argued some more, and finally Williams suggested he intervene to make peace.
The Indians said they would spend the next month burning Plymouth Colony, and then they would talk to him.
The Indians never used Rogers Williams’ services as a peacemaker. They did, however, tell him the safe way home.
Old Roger Williams lived for another seven years.
With thanks to Mayflower: A Story of Courage, Community and War by Nathaniel Philbrick. This story was updated in 2020.